Insights
Risks in public markets are mounting. Here’s where PE fits in.
With public market valuations at historic highs and markets susceptible to a spike in volatility, private equity could be considered a compelling portfolio diversifier.
Risks in public markets are mounting. Here’s where PE fits in.
Written by Mike O'Sullivan, Chief Economist
October 7, 2025

The US stock market entered September with volatility at historically low levels.¹ Credit spreads are at lows and stock market valuations at historic highs.² In that context it is likely that public markets will see a spike in volatility through October.

The financialisation of equity markets

The notion of market volatility has changed somewhat since academics studied market seasonality. In particular, equity markets have become more intensely financialised — for example, on many trading days one-day options account for close to 80% of option market volume, according to the Nasdaq exchange. In addition, there are now more ETFs (exchange traded funds) than stocks in the US.³ Add to that record levels of market concentration (the top ten companies in the US account for 40% of SPX market cap, according to Apollo⁴).

To that extent, the financialisation of markets introduces a new form of volatility to equity markets that can magnify upward moves, especially in single stocks, and very likely also downward moves. This effect also leads to a lower correlation between, say, private equity and stocks.

Private markets have historically shown lower volatility in certain periods

This degree of systematic volatility is not present in private markets — though they carry its own risks, particularly capital loss and illiquidity. In this respect, holding private assets in a portfolio will help to diminish the risks associated with market volatility.

To illustrate this, we have analysed the volatility of the major equity indices – the S&P 500 and the Russell 2000 — as well as that of the major private asset classes (private equity, venture, fund of funds and private debt) using data back to 2000 from the PitchBook Private Capital Indices.

From 2000 to 2025 the annualised volatility of the S&P 500 and the Russell 2000 was 16.5% and 21.4% respectively. In contrast, annualised volatility for the PitchBook Private Equity Index and the Private Debt Index was 9.5% and 7.7% respectively. See the table below for data on selected asset classes.

Source: Pitchbook, LSEG Workspace, Moonfare calculations Note: Quarterly volatility represents the standard deviation of quarterly returns. Annual volatility is derived by multiplying the quarterly figure by √4.

Adding PE may increase portfolio risk-return profile

As a result, the inclusion of private equity assets in standard portfolios helps to improve the risk-reward relationship. To illustrate, a typical 60/40 portfolio made up of US equities and bonds has a risk/return trade-off, or Sharpe ratio, of 0.73 (higher Sharpe ratio means more return per unit of risk).

Reconfiguring such a portfolio with 20% private equity boosts the risk-return ratio to 0.88. This rises to 1.07 when we compute the risk/return ratio for a typical European family office, where the allocation to private equity is higher at 36%. Although, having said this, it should be noted that past performance is not a guide to future results.

With public market valuations at historic highs and markets susceptible to a spike in volatility, the case for including private equity in a portfolio becomes more compelling.

Join The Satellite to stay on top of private equity
A detailed white paper on returns and volatility across asset classes will be available to Moonfare clients in coming weeks. Sign-up to our newsletter to receive your report.

An examination of the behaviour of public and private asset markets over time shows that during the global financial crisis stock market volatility was twice that of private markets, and even more so during the dot-com crisis. In general, private market volatility is more sensitive to macroeconomic risks. Private equity volatility tends to be higher in a recession-type environment, as opposed to general market sell-offs.

Important notice: This content is for informational purposes only. Moonfare does not provide investment advice. You should not construe any information or other material provided as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice. If you are unsure about anything, you should seek financial advice from an authorised advisor. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future returns. Don’t invest unless you’re prepared to lose all the money you invest. Private equity is a high-risk investment and you are unlikely to be protected if something goes wrong. Subject to eligibility. Please see https://www.moonfare.com/disclaimers.
Authors
Mike O'Sullivan, Chief Economist
Chief Economist
Mike O'Sullivan, Chief Economist
Mike is a Chief Economist and Senior Advisor at Moonfare. He has twenty years’ experience in global financial markets, most recently as CIO in the International Wealth Management Division of Credit Suisse. He was also a member of Harvest Innovation Advisory, a senior adviser at WestExec and a board member of the Jane Goodall Legacy Foundation. He has taught finance and economics at Oxford and Princeton, while regularly contributing to numerous journals and media outlets, including Forbes and CNBC. Mike studied in Cork and received MPhil and DPhil degrees at Balliol College, Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar.
Join Moonfare Now.
Benefit from what institutional investors already know: the greatest shareholder value comes from private markets, and funds like those offered on Moonfare have generated an average IRR of 19% — outperforming the S&P 500 by 13%.*
partnerships-image
Join The Satellite.
Weekly updates on Investment and Finance.
Subscribe Now
arrow icon
arrow icon