Dividend Recapitalization

Key takeaways

• A dividend recapitalization involves taking on new debt to pay a special dividend to shareholders.
• It alters a company's capital structure by increasing debt and reducing equity.
• Dividend recaps are commonly used by private equity firms to realise returns on their investments prior to exiting a portfolio company.
• While providing immediate returns to shareholders, dividend recaps increase a company's default risk.
• The strategy's success depends on the company's ability to manage and repay the increased debt load and associated interest payments.

What is a dividend recapitalization?

A dividend recapitalization, often referred to as a dividend recap, is a financial strategy where a company takes on new debt to pay a special dividend to its shareholders. This process effectively replaces equity with debt in the company's capital structure.

Basics of how a dividend recapitalization works

In a dividend recap, a company borrows funds, usually through a new loan issued in the syndicated leveraged loan markets or by issuing bonds. The borrowed money is then used to pay a large, one-time dividend to shareholders. This process increases the company's debt while simultaneously reducing its equity.

Key components and structure of a dividend recap model

1. New debt issuance: The company secures new loans or issues bonds.
2. Dividend distribution: The borrowed funds are paid out to shareholders as a special dividend.
3. Altered capital structure: The company's debt-to-equity ratio increases.
4. Repayment plan: The company must have a strategy to repay the new debt over time.

Recapitalization example to illustrate the concept

Let's consider a hypothetical example:

Company A has the following capital structure:

• Equity: $100 million
• Existing debt: $50 million

Its shareholders decide to do a dividend recapitalization. It borrows an additional $40 million and distributes this amount as a dividend to its shareholders. After the recap, the new capital structure looks like this:

• Equity: $60 million ($100 million - $40 million dividend)
• Total debt: $90 million ($50 million existing debt + $40 million new debt)

This process has increased the company’s leverage and provided a payout to its shareholders.

Dividend recaps in private equity

Why private equity firms use dividend recapitalizations

Private equity firms often use dividend recaps as a way to realise returns on their investments without selling their stake in the portfolio company. This strategy allows them to:

1. Crystallise value from their investments earlier in the holding period.
2. Increase returns on equity by leveraging the portfolio company’s balance sheet.
3. Maintain control and ownership of the company for potential future growth and value creation before an exit.

Benefits for private equity investors and portfolio companies

For private equity investors:

• Early returns on investment: Dividend recaps allow private equity firms to realise a portion of their investment's value without selling their stake in the portfolio company. This early monetisation can significantly improve a PE fund's overall performance.

• Improved internal rate of return (IRR): IRR is particularly sensitive to the timing of cash flows. By receiving substantial cash distributions earlier in the investment lifecycle, private equity firms can demonstrate strong performance to their limited partners, potentially aiding in future fundraising efforts.
• Potential tax advantages compared to capital gains: Dividend recapitalizations can offer significant tax benefits to shareholders, particularly in comparison to realising capital gains through a sale of equity. In many jurisdictions, dividends are taxed at a lower rate than capital gains.

For portfolio companies:

• Potential tax shield from increased interest payments: The interest payments on the new debt taken on for the dividend recapitalization are typically tax-deductible. This means the company can deduct these interest expenses from its taxable income, creating a potential tax shield on earnings from increased interest payments.
• Discipline imposed by debt servicing requirements: The increased debt load from a dividend recap creates new financial obligations for the company, which can instil greater discipline in management. Regular debt payments require consistent cash flow generation, encouraging management to focus on operational efficiency and cost control.

Dividend recaps also carry risk

1. Can increase company's financial risk and leverage: By adding debt to a company's balance sheet, dividend recaps increase their leverage ratio. This higher debt burden means the company must allocate more of its cash flow to interest payments and debt repayment, leaving less room for error in its operations.
2. May limit future borrowing capacity: Additional debt may exhaust much of a company’s borrowing capacity. This can constrain its ability to raise capital for future growth opportunities, strategic acquisitions, or necessary investments in the business. Lenders may be hesitant to extend further credit to a highly leveraged company, or may only do so at much higher interest rates.
   
3. Can negatively impact credit ratings: Credit rating agencies often view dividend recaps unfavourably, as they increase a company's debt without adding productive assets or improving its business prospects. Any rerating is likely to lead to higher costs on future borrowing.
4. Can reduce financial flexibility for future investments or economic downturns: The increased debt service requirements from a dividend recap can reduce a company's financial flexibility. This can be particularly problematic during economic downturns or industry-specific challenges when cash flows may be stressed, potentially putting it at a disadvantage compared to less leveraged competitors and pushing the company towards financial distress or even bankruptcy.

Dividend recapitalizations can be a powerful tool for PE funds that are best suited to borrower-friendly debt market conditions, i.e. when interest rates are low or falling. 

While this form of financial engineering can greatly enhance investor returns, particularly IRRs, it also comes with increased risks due to the higher leverage imposed on a company’s balance sheet. 

The success of a dividend recap strategy depends on careful consideration of a company's financial health, market conditions, and long-term strategic goals. When used prudently, dividend recaps can be an effective way to balance shareholder returns with ongoing value creation in a company.

Important notice: This content is for informational purposes only. Moonfare does not provide investment advice. You should not construe any information or other material provided as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice. If you are unsure about anything, you should seek financial advice from an authorised advisor. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future returns. Don’t invest unless you’re prepared to lose all the money you invest. Private equity is a high-risk investment and you are unlikely to be protected if something goes wrong. Subject to eligibility. Please see https://www.moonfare.com/disclaimers.